I see it all the time. You hire someone talented, they deliver something that looks right, and a few months later you’re looking at your website next to your sales page next to what your team is producing and something is just… off. You can’t name it. The colors are fine, the fonts are fine, the logo is fine. But when you put it all together, it doesn’t feel like you.
And then you start second-guessing yourself. Maybe the problem is your taste. Maybe you can’t articulate what you want. Maybe you’re just hard to work with.
Here’s what I actually think: The process wasn’t right from the beginning.
The Brief is Not the Same as Understanding Your Business
There’s a difference between handing someone a brief and working with someone who actually understands how your business functions.
A brief is a document. It tells someone what to make. Understanding your business means knowing your market, your business model, your vision, and how all the pieces fit together. When you hand a brief to someone, you’re giving them instructions. When you work with someone who understands your business, you’re working with a strategist. The output is different. The process is different. The result actually works.
Most brand work starts with a brief. You fill out a form, you describe what you want, and then the designer goes away and comes back with something. That’s a process. But it’s not the process that produces a brand that feels like you.
What Actually Matters
Before someone should start designing anything, they need to understand your business at a level that goes beyond your description of it.
What kind of business do you actually run?
Not “I’m a consultant,” but what kind of consultant, who do you work with, what do you help them with, and what’s your business model? Are you selling one-on-one services, group programs, digital products, or workshops? Because a B2B consultant who needs to send proposals and run workshops needs a completely different visual language than someone selling digital products to consumers.
Where will this brand show up?
This is the question most people skip. Will it live in Google Docs and slide decks, in sales proposals, on social media, on packaging, in print, on your website? If someone doesn’t know this upfront, they might create something beautiful that breaks the moment you try to use it in real life. I’ve seen brand guides with coffee mug mockups for consultants who will never use a coffee mug. Nobody asked what they would actually use.
What’s currently not working?
If you already have a brand and something about it isn’t functioning, say so. Tell them the colors look muddy on screen or the fonts are hard to read in presentations or nothing feels cohesive when you put assets side by side. This gives someone specific problems to solve, not a vague direction to make it better.
What do you want to feel like?
Not what do you want it to look like, but how should someone feel when they see your brand, what impression should it leave, and what should it communicate about who you are and what you do?
These questions matter because they’re the difference between someone executing a brief and someone building a brand that actually serves your business.
How to Know If Someone Gets It
A portfolio shows you what someone can make look good. It doesn’t show you whether they understand how to ask the right questions.
When you’re considering working with someone, pay attention to their process. How do they start? What do they need from you? What questions do they ask? Do they want to understand your business or do they just want your brand brief?
If someone shows you a portfolio and talks about their design aesthetic, they’re focused on the visual. If someone asks you about your business model, your target market, and where your brand will live, they’re focused on strategy. You need someone focused on strategy.
Look at their case studies. Do they talk about the thinking behind the work, or do they just show you pretty pictures? The ones who explain the reasoning are the ones who asked the right questions first.
Pay attention to how they present themselves. Are they confident in their thinking or are they defensive about their work? Are they willing to push back on a brief that doesn’t make sense, or do they just execute what you tell them? Someone who’s secure in their process will push back. Someone who’s not will just do what you ask.
What Happens When Someone Understands Your Business
When you work with someone who actually gets your business, the process feels different. They ask you things you didn’t expect. They challenge your thinking. They make connections you didn’t see. And then the work they deliver doesn’t just look good, it actually functions.
Your social graphics feel like your sales page. Your email templates feel like your website. Your proposals feel like your brand. Everything feels like you because someone took the time to understand who you are before they started making visual decisions.
That’s what matters. That’s what makes the difference between a rebrand that feels off and a rebrand that feels like you finally showed up the way you meant to.
—
Ready to work with someone who understands your business first? Check out the VIP Weeks
Be the first to comment